Yankees Catering Tip Claims Revived on Appeal
A New York appellate court revived a claim alleging that a Yankee Stadium catering business failed to pass along certain gratuities to waitstaff. The court rejected a federal-preemption argument in a state-law claim.
Read More
- Final award.
- Yankees certification provides related coverage.
- Wage and hour information offers broader context.
What Was the Tip Dispute About?
The workers alleged that money collected in connection with catering services should have been paid to them under the applicable state-law rules. The legal question depended on how the charges were represented and the governing law.
What Did the Appeals Court Decide?
The appellate court held that the state-law claim was not barred on the asserted federal-preemption ground. That allowed the claim to proceed; it wasn’t a final award of the requested tips.
How Are Service Charges and Tips Different Under Labor Law?
Service charges are mandatory fees added to a bill by the restaurant, while tips are voluntary payments given by customers based on their discretion. Under labor law, tips belong to the employee who receives them, whereas service charges are considered part of the business's revenue until distributed.

US
ES